*Note: OVU was a provisional member of the West Virginia Athletic Conference (WVIAC) from 2000-2003.  OVU has been a full-time member of the WVIAC and NCAA since 2004. 

All-Conference Members, WVIAC:

2007
2nd Team 
DH -Brandon Durben, Sr

Honorable Mention
1B-Andrew Lore, Sr
SS-Jesse Young, Jr
OF-DJ Schreckengost, Sr

2006
1st Team
OF-DJ Schreckengost, Jr

2nd Team
1B-Andrew Lore, Jr
SS-Jesse Young, Soph
OF-Wayne Toms, Sr

Honorable Mention
2B-Brad McConnachie, Jr

*Co-Coach of the Year: Chad Porter*

2005
2nd Team
OF-Darren Graham, Sr

Honorable Mention
1B-Andrew Lore, Soph

2004
2nd Team
P-Adam Copeland, Soph
DH-Andrew Lore, Fr

Honorable Mention
SS-Josh Hudkins, Sr
OF-Brad Gardner, Sr
OF-Josh Wakeman, Sr

2003
WVIAC 2nd Team
OF-Darren Graham, Jr

WVIAC Honorable Mention
OF-Josh Wakeman, Jr

2002
WVIAC Honorable Mention
Josh Wakeman
Darren Graham
Andrew Christian

*NCCAA Mid-East Region Player of the Year*
Andrew Christian

NCCAA All Mid-East Region
Andrew Christian
Jesse Wilson
Darren Graham
Josh Wakeman
Matt Miller

2001
WVIAC 2nd Team
Dustin Nippert
Jesse Seaton

WVIAC Honorable Mention
Anthony Boughner

*NCCAA All-American & Mid East Player of the Year*
Anthony Boughner

All Mid-East Region
Chad Porter
Jesse Seaton
Dustin Nippert
Anthony Boughner
Andrew Christian

2000
WVIAC 2nd Team
Anthony Boughner

NCCAA All Mid-East Region
Anthony Boughner
Andrew Christian
Dustin Nippert
Charles Somers
Jesse Seaton
Jeff Smith
Greg Kupfner

1999
NAIA All Mid-East Region
Charles Somers

1998
NSCAA All-American
Chuck Rinehimer
Bob Kwiatkowswi

1997
NSCAA All-American
Chuck Rinehimer
Mike Pinkston
Mike Anderson

1995
NSCAA All American
Chuck Rinehimer
Danny Singletary

Legend:
NAIA-National Association for Intercollegiate Athletics
NCCAA-National Christian College Athletic Association
NSCAA-National Small College Athletic Association