* = conference game Bold = Home Games
| Date | Opponent | Time | Score |
NOVEMBER |
| 11/5/09 | University of the Cumberlands (Exhibition) | 7:00pm | |
| 11/12/09 | Alice Lloyd College (Exhibition) | 7:00pm | |
| 11/17/09 | at Malone University | 7:00pm | W 65-57 [Box Score] |
| 11/24/09 | Seton Hill University* | 5:30pm | L 63-52 [Box Score] |
DECEMBER |
| 12/1/09 | at Fairmont State University* | 5:30pm | L 78-47 [Box Score] |
| 12/5/09 | at Shepherd University* | 4:00pm | L 87-57 [Box Score] |
| 12/8/09 | Ohio Dominican University | 7:00pm | W 55-54 [Box Score] |
| 12/12/09 | at Alice Lloyd College | 4:00pm | L 68-67 [Box Score] |
JANUARY |
| 1/5/10 | at Urbana University | 7:00pm | rescheduled 1/25/10 |
| 1/9/10 | Davis & Elkins College* | 2:00pm | L 82-57 [Box Score] |
| 1/11/10 | at Alderson-Broaddus College* | 5:15pm | L 75-57 [Box Score] |
| 1/14/10 | Bluefield State College* | 5:30pm | W 83-57 [Box Score] |
| 1/16/10 | at Concord University* | 4:00pm | L 76-54 [Box Score] |
| 1/18/10 | at Salem International* | 5:30pm | W 65-35 [Box Score] |
| 1/21/10 | University of Pitt-Johnstown* | 5:30pm | L 68-62 [Box Score] |
| 1/23/10 | at West Virginia State* | 5:30pm | L 74-52 [Box Score] |
| 1/25/10 | at Urbana University | 7:00pm | L 72-69 [Box Score] |
| 1/28/10 | West Liberty University* | 5:30pm | L 85-54 [Box Score] |
| 1/30/10 | University of Charleston* | 2:00pm | L 62-45 [Box Score] |
FEBRUARY |
2/1/10 | at Wheeling Jesuit University | 5:30pm | L 73-56 [Box Score] |
2/4/10 | Glenville State College* | 5:30pm | L 126-92 [Box Score] |
2/6/10 | at West Virginia Wesleyan* | 2:00pm | postponed 2/25 |
2/8/10 | Urbana University | 7:00pm | L 73-49 [Box Score] |
2/11/10 | Fairmont State University* | 5:30pm | L 81-42 [Box Score] |
2/13/10 | at Seton Hill University* | 4:00pm | L 77-46 [Box Score] |
2/15/10 | at University of Pitt-Johnstown* | 5:30pm | L 67-52 [Box Score] |
2/18/10 | Shepherd University* | 5:30pm | L 89-58 [Box Score] |
| 2/20/10 | Wheeling Jesuit University* | 2:00pm | L 68-60 [Box Score] |
| 2/22/10 | at West Liberty State* | 5:30pm | L 91-60 |
| 2/25/10 | at West Virginia Wesleyan College* | 5:30pm | L 75-43 |
| 2/27/10 | Salem International University* | 2:00pm | L 65-58 |
| | W | L | | W | L | | W | L |
| OVERALL RECORD | 4 | 23 | HOME | 2 | 11 | AWAY | 2 | 12 |
| CONFERENCE RECORD | 2 | 20 | HOME | 1 | 10 | AWAY | 1 | 10 |
